National Patient Groups File Amicus Brief in Federal Appellate Court Defending Patient Protections in the Affordable Care Act
January 21, 2011
The nation’s leading groups representing patients and families living with cancer, diabetes, heart disease or stroke jointly filed an amicus brief in federal appellate court today in support of provisions of the Affordable Care Act that are critical for people with life-threatening chronic diseases.
The American Cancer Society, the American Cancer Society Cancer Action Network, the American Diabetes Association and the American Heart Association filed as amici curiae in the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit, which is hearing the appeal of a district court decision in a case brought by the Thomas More Law Center. In that decision, Judge George C. Steeh of the U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of Michigan ruled the law’s “individual responsibility” or “individual mandate” requirement to be constitutional.
Following is a statement from the four organizations that filed the amicus brief:
“Our organizations, which represent tens of millions of people across the country who are living with cancer, diabetes, heart disease or stroke, have decided after careful thought and deliberation to file an amicus brief in support of provisions of the Affordable Care Act (ACA) that are critical for people with life-threatening chronic diseases.
“Our organizations believe that critical patient protections in the Affordable Care Act, including those that end discrimination in the insurance market against people with chronic diseases, would not be sustainable without the individual responsibility requirement. These provisions significantly improve the health care system for chronic disease patients and their families by expanding access to quality, affordable health care; reducing the cost burden on families; and refocusing the system to emphasize prevention.
“For decades our organizations have worked to expand access to health care nationwide and to boost our nation’s emphasis on disease prevention and management. As any patient knows, chronic disease strikes people without regard for their opinions or political persuasion. We regret that the current health care debate has been so divisive to the country, but we continue our determined efforts to support and strengthen provisions of the law that enable patients with chronic diseases to access quality, affordable health care.
“Provisions of the ACA that are already in effect prohibit insurance companies from denying coverage to children with pre-existing conditions, eliminate lifetime benefit limits and restrict annual benefit limits that can cause the sudden termination of coverage, prohibit the unfair rescission of coverage, and enable children to stay on their parents’ health plan until age 26. Beginning in 2014, additional provisions will guarantee health coverage to all applicants regardless of pre-existing conditions, prohibit insurance companies from charging people more for coverage because of their health status, establish minimum essential benefits for plans sold in health benefit exchanges and make quality care more affordable through tax credits based on financial need and expanded Medicaid eligibility.
“These and the law’s other patient protections can only work if all Americans are required to have health insurance. Without that requirement, healthy people tend to avoid buying insurance until they need it, leaving insurance plans to cover a sicker population and driving up costs for everyone in the health care system.
“Under the individual responsibility requirement, having health insurance becomes a shared responsibility for all Americans – we each pay into the system with the security of knowing that we will have access to quality, affordable health care when we need it.
“But without the patient protections that the individual responsibility provision makes possible, large numbers of people with life-threatening chronic diseases will be denied care or charged far more than they can afford for it. Research studies individually conducted by our groups and others clearly show that people without health insurance are more likely than those with insurance to suffer from advanced-stage chronic disease.
“Health insurance coverage is essential to leading a healthy life. We urge that the individual responsibility provision be upheld so critical patient protections that are increasing access to quality, affordable health care can be successfully implemented.”
The American Diabetes Association is leading the fight to Stop Diabetes and its deadly consequences and fighting for those affected by diabetes. The Association funds research to prevent, cure and manage diabetes; delivers services to hundreds of communities; provides objective and credible information; and gives voice to those denied their rights because of diabetes. Since 1940, our mission has been to prevent and cure diabetes and to improve the lives of all people affected by diabetes. For more information please call the American Diabetes Association at 1-800-DIABETES (800-342-2383) or visit diabetes.org. Information from both these sources is available in English and Spanish.